Assessment and diagnosis
Initial stages of the diagnostic process are to distinguish dementia
from other situations where similar symptoms arise. These are easily summarized as the
‘Five Ds’:
- Depression
- Delirium
- Drugs
- Decline of memory with normal aging
- Situations where there is diagnostic difficulty
A series of tests are therefore recommended which include
neuropsychological profiles, brain imaging studies and laboratory investigations
(
see Table 6). These tests will help to determine the causes of dementia, exclude
comorbid conditions and establish the underlying cause of the dementia.
Table 6. Recommended investigations in suspected dementia
Neuropsychological assessment
An examination of the mental state may reveal evidence of
self-neglect, concomitant physical illness and disinhibited or inappropriate
behaviour, such as marked agitation, anxiety, irritability or retardation (both
possibly indicating depression). Hostile or guarded behaviour may suggest underlying
paranoid ideas, whereas a poor attention span may indicate clouding of consciousness
and may be helpful in differentiating delirium from dementia. The patient’s speech may
also reveal word-finding difficulties or evidence of aphasia or dysarthria.
Other presenting abnormalities of verbal output observed in dementia
may include:
- Perseveration – the patient repeats answers to the previous questions
when asked new questions
- Palilalia – repeating the patient’s own verbalizations
- Logoclonia – when the last syllable is repeated
- Logorrhoea – meaningless outpouring of words
- Echolalia – echoing of examiner’s speech
- Echopraxia – imitating behaviour
Content of thought is also impoverished in dementia, but questioning
may reveal the presence of delusions, perceptual disturbances, depressive ideas or the
patient may elaborate on psychotic experiences, such as paranoia or misidentifications.
All patients presenting with dementia should undergo a cognitive
assessment using the MMSE or similar tests to confirm a diagnosis and quantify the
degree of cognitive impairment.
Neuropsychological profiles are different in cortical and subcortical
types of dementia (
see Table 5) and this can be informative in diagnosis and may help
distinguish between AD or other dementias. For example, cortical dementias, such as AD,
show impairments in cognitive abilities (ie, memory and language) and parietal lobe
functions, such as praxis; therefore, impairment of day-to-day memory may suggest AD.
In contrast, subcortical dementias, such as Parkinson’s disease, typically show a
pattern of slowing, executive dysfunction and mild changes in memory.
Neuroimaging
A selection of neuroimaging techniques are available to identify
structural causes of dementia, such as subdural haematoma, tumours and normal-pressure
hydrocephalus.
Neuroimaging techniques to investigate dementia include:
Structural imaging – reflecting brain anatomy:
- Computed Tomography (CT) (a CT scan without contrast should routinely be
performed to exclude reversible causes of dementia)
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
Functional imaging – indicates brain function by measuring
cerebral blood flow and cell metabolism:
- Computed Tomography (CT) (a CT scan without contrast should routinely be
performed to exclude reversible causes of dementia)
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
The detection of characteristic abnormalities in AD and other
neurodegenerative dementias on both structural imaging (MRI and CT) and functional
imaging, such as SPECT and PET, can aid differential diagnosis. For example, CT scans
can identify brain lesions (tumours), cerebral infarctions, subdural or extradural
haematomas, cerebral abscesses and hydrocephalus, lobar cerebral atrophy,
cerebrovascular disease and cortical atrophy (
see Figure 2). MRI scans of patients with
AD in the earliest stages can show evidence of atrophy of the hippocampus and medial
temporal lobe, reflecting the underlying pathology (
see Figure 3). MRI scans can
identify lesions in cerebrovascular disease indicating vascular dementia (
see Figures
4 and
5). Also, MRI scans may show knife-edge focal atrophy of frontal and/or temporal
areas that is often asymmetrical indicating FTD (
see Figure 6).
Figure 2. CT scan of patient with Alzheimer's disease
showing cortical atrophy
Figure 3. MRI showing hippocampal atrophy
Figure 4. MRI showing multiple infarcts
Figure 5. MRI showing small vessel disease
Figure 6. MRI showing frontal atrophy
Points for consideration in neuroimaging of vascular dementia
- Multiple large infarcts suggest repeated embolism, therefore investigations
should be directed towards detecting the source of embolism)
- Lacunar infarcts suggest poorly controlled hypertension
- Ischaemic changes suggest small vessel disease – possibly inducing a
gradual decline as seen in AD
What are the advantages and disadvantages of commonly used
neuroimaging techniques?
- CT scans &ndash noncontrast CT used as a routine to primarily exclude brain
lesions and identify cerebrovascular disease
- MRI – better resolution than CT, but takes longer. Apparatus is more
claustrophobic and noisy than CT. MRI provides better images of intracranial
structures, especially cerebral white matter and is more sensitive at picking
up vascular lesions than CT. MRI cannot be carried out when a patient has a
cardiac pacemaker or metallic intracranial aneurysm clips. MRI is particularly
useful in identifying vascular dementia
- SPET/SPECT – involves administration of compounds that are distributed
in the brain according to cerebral blood flow, thus showing a measure of
cerebral activity. SPECT investigations commonly measure blood flow but
muscarinic and dopamine receptors can be imaged. Useful in identification of
FTD
- PET – directly measures cerebral metabolic activity and can assess
cerebral metabolism, cerebral blood flow and cerebral receptors. Can provide
regional comparisons between lobes, as well as absolute cerebral activity. Can
be used to image receptor and transmitter systems that may be of use in
detailing the pathophysiology of dementia and monitoring treatment response.
Recently developed ligands allow imaging of amyloid
Laboratory investigations
Laboratory investigations include routine biochemistry assays (
see
Table 6) to eliminate potentially treatable and reversible causes of dementia, such as
metabolic, toxic or endocrine causes or drug reactions causing dementia symptoms.
How useful is apolipoprotein E genotyping?
Apolipoprotein E genotyping may be useful as an adjunct to clinical
and radiological assessment in patients with definite dementia and uncertain AD, but
ApoE assays are not predictive and should be avoided as a predictive test in
asymptomatic patients, even those with familial risk of AD owing to a lack of
sensitivity and specificity of the test.