Psychosocial interventions
- Addressing the individual, social and environmental aspects of a person’s life
can prevent or minimize the disability associated with neurological impairment.
- Psychosocial approaches need to be individualized and tailored to the person’s
needs, personality, biography, goals, strengths, and preferences [Woods, 2001].
- The aim of psychosocial approaches should be to enhance the person’s sense of
self and quality of life [Karuza, 1991].
- There is no single optimal psychosocial approach, there is a need to develop a
range of flexible psychosocial approaches [Karuza, 1991].
- Multidimensional assessment is essential to ensure effective interventions
[Karuza, 1991].
The psychosocial management of dementia includes social and
environmental approaches to the care of patients with dementia, as well as psychosocial
and behavioural approaches. A useful classification of behaviours has been devised,
dividing them into three categories:
- Physically aggressive
- Verbally aggressive
- Physically nonaggressive [Cohen-Mansfield, 2000].
These have been linked to different causes. For example, physical
aggression most commonly occurs during personal care and may be a function of the
nature of the interaction between the carer and the person with dementia. Finding
alternative approaches to personal care can prove useful.
In contrast, verbal agitation occurs most commonly when the person
is alone or during personal care and, as such, may be linked to pain, discomfort or a
need for social contact. The extent of undetected pain in people with dementia is
well-documented, so appropriate care for behaviour may include medical treatment for
pain. Simulated presence therapy addresses the person’s social need by providing an
audiotape of a close relative talking about shared memories. This has led to decreased
agitation for some patients [Woods, 1995].
Physically nonaggressive behaviours, such as wandering, are associated
with stimulation seeking. Providing the person with something to do has been shown to
reduce behavioural aspects of dementia [Teri, 1991, Rovner, 1996].
Depression and challenging behaviours
A strong association exits between the lack of meaningful activity
and the presence of depression [Rabinovich, 1992] and challenging behaviours
[Cohen-Mansfield, 1998].
Therapeutic activity programmes have been used to decrease disruptive
behaviour by providing engagement in pleasant activities [Teri, 1991]. Rovner et
al. randomly assigned agitated residents to either a treatment or control condition.
In the treatment condition residents attended an activity programme where the goal was
physical, mental and social stimulation which included exercise, music, crafts,
relaxation and reminiscence [Rovner, 1996]. In addition, each resident’s medication
was reviewed and psychiatric input received. Residents in the treatment groups showed
significant reduction in behavioural disturbance and use of psychotropic drugs and
restraints.
How can depression and challenging behaviours be improved
nonpharmacologically in those with dementia?
Physical designs – appropriate physical designs can minimize decline and improve functioning in patients with dementia. For example, low lighting has been linked to confusion and agitation [Cohen-Mansfield, 1998, Cohen-Mansfield, 1986], whereas noise is linked to agitation and poor functional performance. Changing these factors may improve the patient’s condition. The potential exists to prolong independence, promote sense of safety and prevent development of ‘challenging behaviours’.
Functional competence/daily living skills – there is a growing
body of evidence that suggests that appropriate interventions can help maintain daily
living skills, at least for those with mild to moderate impairments [Lawton, 2000]. For
example, in a nursing home setting, residents get the most social contact from staff by
exhibiting dependent behaviours and interventions have been designed to reverse this
dynamic [Baltes, 1992, Baltes, 1994]. Beck et al. taught nursing assistants to use
strategies to promote independence in dressing with 90 cognitively impaired nursing
home residents [Beck, 1997]. During the first week of treatment, 75% of residents
improved one or more levels of dressing independence. After six weeks of intervention
they found a significant improvement in dressing independence.
Communication and social interaction – psychological,
behavioural and environmental interventions are used to improve memory, communication,
activities of daily living and emotional well being [Lawton, 2000, Woods, 2002]. Most
of these interventions rely on carers to initiate or respond in ways that compensate
for deficits and support the abilities of the person with dementia. There are several
ways that families and carers can affect a person’s quality of life. For example,
encouraging carers to use memory books increases the amount and quality of social
interaction with people, even those who have advanced dementia [Bourgeois, 1996]. In
this support framework, those with advanced dementia demonstrate increased verbal
interaction.
Verbal prompts and cues can help people with dementia regain and
maintain everyday abilities such as dressing. Using Reality Orientation (RO), where
the carer provides the person with visual and verbal cues in order to help with
orientation to time, place or person improves behaviour and cognition [Spector, 1999].
This orientation can take place either in groups or in one-on-one interactions.
Carers can also assist people with dementia to recall events from
their past, facilitated by the use of personalized aids, such as photos or memorabilia,
either in one-to-one or in group sessions.
Validation therapy affirms, rather than confronts, a person’s
sense of reality and makes an effort to compensate for a person’s difficulty in
communicating by addressing the underlying meaning of speech and behaviour. The
listener ‘validates’ what is said by listening to the emotional meaning
rather than the factual content of what is said. This can be used in group settings or
during one-on-one interactions. However, evidence of the effectiveness of validation
therapy is largely anecdotal.
Psychoeducational interventions are being used in clinical settings
with people with dementia and their families. They are used to help people adapt both
emotionally and behaviourally to living with cognitive symptoms [Woods, 1999]. These
include cognitive rehabilitation and memory training, psychotherapy [Frazer, 2000] and
peer support groups [Yale, 1995].
Helping caregivers is a critical component of comprehensive dementia
care. Counselling, training programs and continued support can decrease caregiver
distress and depression and delay nursing home admission [Brodarty, 1989; Brodarty,
1997; Mittelman, 1996; Brodarty, 2003]. Referral to the Alzheimer's Association or
Society is good procedure, national contact numbers can be found by going to the
Alzheimer's Society website
(www.alzheimers.org.uk). In the United Kingdom telephone: +44 20 7306 0606.
International contact numbers can be found by going to the Alzheimer’s Disease
International website
(www.alz.co.uk). In the USA telephone: +1 312 335-8700
(www.alz.org).