Risk Factors
| Definition of risk factor and risk indicator |
The term ‘atherosclerosis risk factor’
is used to denote attributes of persons that are predictive of future
manifestations of clinical atherosclerosis with evidence of probable
causality. In contrast, the term ‘risk indicator’ indicates
a statistical predictor whose causal role is uncertain.
|
Risk factors are either non-modifiable or modifiable:
| Risk factors for clinical atherosclerosis |
| Non-modifiable |
Modifiable* |
| Age
Male gender
Family history of CHD
Presence of CHD
Menopause
|
Biomedical |
Dyslipidaemia
Hypertension
Diabetes |
| Behavioural |
Smoking |
| Lifestyle |
Physical inactivity
Diet |
| * These are firmly established
risk factors supported by the results of many epidemiological, clinical
and experimental studes. |
Dyslipidaemia
Atherosclerosis is a multifactorial disease and the combination of different levels of aetiological factors (see Figure 9) is responsible for the variable extension, severity and preferential localisation of the atherosclerotic lesion. Dyslipidaemia is particularly, but not exclusively, associated with CHD. Hypertension is above all deleterious for cerebral and renal circulation, while cigarette smoking and diabetes have, in addition, a prominent role in the obliterating arterial disease of the lower limbs.
|
| Figure 9. Aetiopathogenesis of coronary
heart diseases. |
What is the role of plasma cholesterol?
In epidemiological studies, high concentrations of plasma cholesterol (hypercholesterolaemia) are closely associated with the development of clinical atherosclerosis both within and between populations. In the inherited disease, known as familial hypercholesterolaemia, the pronounced elevation of LDL concentrations leads to extensive and premature atherosclerosis, involving coronary arteries and causing CHD.
What is the role of oxidised LDL?
Experimental evidence has been provided of enhanced atherogenicity of
LDLs when they undergo oxidative modifications [Diaz,
1997; Tribble, 1999]. Vitamin E that
is carried in blood within LDL particles is thought to be the first
line of protection against oxidation. Oxidised LDLs start an inflammatory
reaction in the arterial wall, involving the production of several molecular
signals, which are responsible for the cellular responses involved in
atherogenesis. In particular, during fatty streak formation (see Figure
3) adhesion molecules and receptors for circulating monocytes and platelets
are expressed on the surface of endothelial cells. Circulating lipoproteins,
once they have entered the arterial wall, undergo phagocytosis by macrophages,
derived from circulating monocytes. Macrophages thus remove LDLs, particularly
those that have been oxidised within the arterial wall by interaction
with platelets and other cells of the intima. This process is enhanced
in the presence of high circulating levels of LDL or remnant particles
(see Plasma lipids and lipoprotein), deriving from
the catabolism of triglyceride-rich lipoproteins. Macrophages become
progressively replete of lipids and are transformed into foam cells.
The foam cells eventually undergo necrosis, thus releasing their lipid
content into the extracellular matrix.
What is the role of triglycerides?
Hypertriglyceridaemia is associated with a high risk of cardiovascular
manifestations, particularly CHD, both in cross-sectional and prospective
epidemiological studies [Austin, 1997;
Gaziano, 1997]. Many mechanisms have
been proposed to explain the atherogenicity of high triglyceride plasma
levels and, among these, an important role has been given to the action
of high plasma concentrations of remnants, especially during the postprandial
phase. In subjects at high risk of CHD, circulating plasminogen-activator
inhibitor (PAI) levels are elevated and are associated with impaired
fibrinolysis and increased risk of atherothrombosis [Juhan-Vague,
2000]. Other potential mechanisms of atherogenesis secondary to
hypertriglyceridaemia include low levels of HDL, the enhanced formation
of small dense LDL (see Figure 5), which are characterised by pronounced
atherogenicity and oxidability, and the interference in haemostatic
processes and fibrinolysis.
What is the role of HDL?
There is strong epidemiological evidence relating low plasma concentrations
of HDL-C to CHD. The mechanism underlying cardiovascular protection
of high levels of HDL-C has not, however, been fully elucidated [Stein,
1999]. One possibility is that high concentrations of HDL promote
RCT (see Centripetal lipoprotein transport:
reverse cholesterol transport) from the arterial wall towards the
liver, for final excretion in the form of bile salts. Another hypothesis
is that HDL may antagonise oxidative processes, possibly through the
action of paraoxonase [Mackness, 1998],
an antioxidant enzyme that is carried within HDL particles and occurs
in low concentrations in the plasma when HDL-C is reduced.
Hypertension
Hypertension represents another well-recognised atherosclerotic risk factor.
Both observational and intervention studies have clearly shown that lower
blood pressure values are paralleled by reduced rates of events of clinical
atherosclerosis [Kannel, 1996].
What is the role of angiotensin II?
Plasma concentrations of angiotensin II, the end product of the renin-angiotensin
system, are often elevated in patients with hypertension. Angiotensin
II has pronounced vasoconstrictive effects and has been suggested to
contribute to atherogenesis, by stimulating smooth muscle cell proliferation
[Ross, 1999], by enhancement of protein
synthesis and eventually hypertrophy of smooth muscle cells. These cells
produce great amounts of proteoglycan, collagen and elastic fibres,
thereby contributing to the early stages of the atherosclerotic process
and to the fibrous component of the plaque. Angiotensin II is also associated
with enhanced activity of smooth muscle cell lipoxygenase, causing LDL
oxidation.
Diabetes
There is wide epidemiological evidence of the independent association of diabetes mellitus with premature and severe atherosclerosis. Both type 1 and type 2 diabetes are associated with a markedly increased risk of CHD, cerebrovascular disease and peripheral vascular disease. Diabetes is a particularly strong cardiovascular risk factor in women and reduces the relative protection of female gender against atherosclerosis.
What are the causes of premature atherosclerosis?
To some extent the premature atherosclerosis is related to the diabetic dyslipidaemia (consisting of hypertriglyceridaemia and low HDL-C levels) and hypertension, which are highly prevalent among patients with diabetes. However, there is evidence that a part of this excess risk must be caused by the direct effect of hyperglycaemia.
What are the effects of hyperglycaemia?
The mechanisms of increased atherogenesis owing to hyperglycaemia are not completely understood, but there are many experimental studies showing the occurrence of endothelial damage, associated with persisting hyperglycaemia and enhanced production of advanced glycosylation end products and free radicals. In addition, it has been postulated that the presence of insulin resistance and/or hyperinsulinaemia, which are common features of type 2 diabetes, might also contribute to the accelerated atherogenesis observed in individuals with diabetes.
Smoking
Cigarette smoking is universally and strongly associated with clinical
atherosclerosis. Among the many toxic substances that are present in
tobacco smoke, nicotine is considered the most dangerous for the arterial
circulation. In general, cigarette smoking is thought to promote oxidative
processes, in addition to producing haemodynamic stress (repeated transitory
increases in blood pressure and heart rate) [Avogaro,
1993; Winniford, 1990].
Nutrition
A large body of evidence supports a major role for nutritional factors
in the development of atherosclerosis. Several large-scale epidemiological
studies have shown an association between a low- saturated fat, low-cholesterol
and fibre-rich diet and low prevalence of clinical atherosclerosis.
Furthermore, a direct relationship has been demonstrated between dietary
trans-fatty acids and cardiovascular disease.
What role do nutritional factors play?
These associations are certainly mediated by the effects of diet on
atherosclerotic risk factors, namely plasma lipids and lipoproteins,
but the paradigm that nutritional factors influence atherosclerosis
exclusively via effects on plasma lipids has been challenged. In particular,
in the Lyon Diet Heart Study, survivors of a previous myocardial infarction
who were randomly allocated to the 'Mediterranean diet' showed a clear
reduction in the rate of cardiovascular events without major effects
on the classical risk factors, including plasma lipids [de
Lorgeril, 1999].
Obesity
Large prospective studies have found that obesity is associated with
increased mortality owing to clinical atherosclerosis. Abdominal obesity
is a strong predictor of myocardial infarction and stroke [Wood,
1998]. The association between obesity and, in particular, visceral
adiposity and CHD, is largely mediated by their adverse influence on
a number of other classical cardiovascular risk factors such as diabetes
and dyslipidaemia (especially high triglycerides and low HDL-C) and
hypertension.
Exercise
The association between a sedentary lifestyle and an increased risk
for cardiovascular diseases has been reported in many epidemiological
studies [Wood, 1998]. Even a modest change
in lifestyle with the adoption of moderate physical activity may be
beneficial. Moreover, there have been many randomised trials on the
effects of physical exercise after myocardial infarction showing a clear
reduction in cardiovascular mortality.
Homocysteine
High plasma levels of the sulphur-containing amino acid homocysteine
have been associated with increased cardiovascular risk [Robinson,
1998]. Some inherited diseases of metabolism have been associated
with pronounced hyperhomocysteinaemia and vascular disease [Bellamy,
1997]. Moderate hyperhomocysteinaemia, owing to vitamin deficit,
has also been demonstrated to be a potential risk factor for cardiovascular
manifestations [Robinson, 1998]. Despite
the large body of evidence supporting high homocysteine plasma levels
as predictors of cardiovascular diseases, it may be more appropriate
to consider hyperhomocysteinaemia as a risk indicator rather than a
risk factor, in view of the lack of large-scale intervention trials.
|